Bay Island Homes with Tudor Architectural style

Welcome to Bay Island, a hidden gem nestled in the picturesque Siesta Key of Sarasota, Florida. This charming subdivision is renowned for its stunning waterfront views, lush tropical landscapes, and a lifestyle that perfectly blends relaxation with recreation. With its close-knit community vibe, Bay Island offers an inviting atmosphere where neighbors become friends and families create lasting memories.

One of the standout features of Bay Island is the enchanting Tudor architectural style that graces many of its homes. These distinctive residences showcase the timeless elegance of Tudor design, characterized by steeply pitched gable roofs, decorative half-timbering, and charming brick or stone facades. Each home tells a story of craftsmanship and tradition, providing a warm and welcoming ambiance that feels like a retreat from the everyday hustle and bustle.

Living in Bay Island means embracing the best of coastal living. Residents can enjoy leisurely strolls along the serene shores of Siesta Key Beach, renowned for its powdery white sand and crystal-clear waters. The community also boasts easy access to a variety of recreational activities, including boating, fishing, and kayaking, making it a paradise for outdoor enthusiasts.

In addition to its natural beauty, Bay Island is conveniently located near local shops, gourmet dining, and vibrant cultural attractions. Whether you’re seeking a peaceful escape or an active lifestyle, Bay Island has something for everyone. Discover your dream home in this enchanting subdivision and experience the magic of Siesta Key living at its finest.

Newest Bay Island Homes with Tudor Architectural style

$2,590,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ Bay Island SubDv. ⋅ 34242 Zip Code ⋅ A4662830 MLS ⋅ Active Status

A Rare Opportunity on North Siesta Key with exceptional weekly income, prime location 350 Feet of Waterfront! Discover this unique multi-family income producing single-story property on Bay Island, offering both beauty and potential. High and dry, the home remained unaffected by recent storms, with 4–5 feet of elevation to spare. Set on a tranquil, tropical lot, this historic location on Garden Lane—once home to the Siesta Key Fish Market—with easy fast access to the bay and Big Pass it is truly a boater’s and fisherman’s paradise. Just a few steps to Shell Beach and its breathtaking sunsets, minutes from the world famous Siesta Beach, Siesta Village with restaurants, shopping, nightlife, quick access to downtown, and St. Armands Circle. You have it all! The property features a classic Florida ranch-style 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom home with a pool, large deck, and lush backyard designed for entertaining, plus a detached 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom guest house. Whether you choose to renovate, rebuild, or divide the lot (buyers to verify with the City), the possibilities are endless with this property!

300 Garden Lane, Siesta Key

Start Your Search

This information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. You should rely on this information only to decide whether or not to further investigate a particular property. BEFORE MAKING ANY OTHER DECISION, YOU SHOULD PERSONALLY INVESTIGATE THE FACTS (e.g. square footage and lot size) with the assistance of an appropriate professional. You may use this information only to identify properties you may be interested in investigating further. All uses except for personal, non-commercial use in accordance with the foregoing purpose are prohibited. Redistribution or copying of this information, any photographs or video tours is strictly prohibited. This information is derived from the Internet Data Exchange (IDX) service provided by San Diego MLS®. Displayed property listings may be held by a brokerage firm other than the broker and/or agent responsible for this display. The information and any photographs and video tours and the compilation from which they are derived is protected by copyright. Compilation © 2026 San Diego MLS®,